Some of these foreign jobs might provide services to u. Offshoring, employment, and aggregate demand springerlink. The impact of offshoring on the labour market has become one of the major issues of concern to policy makers and public opinion. This column revisits the heated debate over international trade, offshoring, and us wages using new data. Workers congressional research service summary offshoring, also known as offshore outsourcing, is the term that came into use more than a decade ago to describe a practice among companies located in the united states of contracting. One of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of the global supply chain is the difference between offsourcing and outsourcing. Based on a sample of 14 sectors of the manufacturing industry during the 19952009 period, our results suggest that offshoring has a positive but small impact on home countrys employment in the. New evidence on international trade, offshoring, and us wages. Companies are getting increasingly comfortable outsourcing as well as offshoring larger parts of their businesses as they realize they are not core.
We show that the motive for offshoring and, consequently, the location of offshore activity, significantly affects the impact of offshoring on parent employment. The worldwide economic recession has forced companies to explore all options to increase efficiencies and cut costs. Section 3 discusses the impact of outsourcing and offshoring for jobs and professions. Lastly, section 4 provides a summary of the economic balance sheet of the impact of outsourcing on emerging market economies, before drawing implications for public policy and management practice. Feenstra university of california, davis, and nber october 1, 2016 abstract we identify first generation statistics to measure offshoring as the share of imported. Statistics to measure offshoring and its impact by robert c. Nonetheless, there are some key areas where additional research might help advance the debate, such as trends in the wages and skill levels of jobs being offshored, reemployment experiences of workers displaced by offshoring, and the extent to which current laws and. Revisiting the employment impact of offshoring sciencedirect. However, less important than technology covers a wide range of impacts, and there is less agreement on the share attributable to offshoring.
Similarly, different types of offshoring have either positive or negative impacts on employment in the home country. Thus, for a 1% increase in the proportion of imported. Offshoring and labor markets in this paper we survey the recent empirical literature on the effects of offshoring on wage, employment and displacement. Nevertheless, new offshoring trends, in particular in services, shows a rising offshoring of. Jan 15, 2018 the positive and negative effects of offshoring on domestic employment brian kovak, lindsay oldenski, nicholas sly 15 january 2018 this column employs the variation in the timing of us treaties to infer the causal effect of tax treatyinduced changes in foreign affiliate employment on changes in us domestic employment. Industry trends in engineering offshoringvivek wadhwa the.
The continuous development of outsourcing and offshoring and the associated. And much of the public concern centers on employment, especially the potential loss of domestic jobs. Iza world of labor offshoring and the migration of jobs. Offshoring, import competition, and the jobless recovery.
The positive and negative effects of offshoring on domestic. Jul 11, 2018 the article uses a demandconstrained smallopeneconomy model in the tradition of keynes and kalecki to study the effects of offshoring on aggregate demand and domestic employment. Offshoringthe transfer of an industrial activity abroadhas become a fact of life for business. Nonsubscribers can browse free online and purchase the pdf ebook andor print edition via our oecd online bookshop.
We have also considered the impact of offshoring on other aspects of business performance, such as wages, productivity and exports. As a result of this heterogeneity, when discussing offshoring, economists should be clear about the effects and type of offshoring which they are discussing. This paper assesses the employment impact of offshoring, in five european countries. The article uses a demandconstrained smallopeneconomy model in the tradition of keynes and kalecki to study the effects of offshoring on aggregate demand and domestic employment. Offshoring and the internationalization of employment. This paper estimates the magnitude of these gains and compares it to the magnitude of employment loss due to worker displacement. The remainder of this paper gives an overview of the literature on each of these topics. In bringing the theory to data i focus solely on the employment impact of offshoring, conditional on factor prices. Downstream offshoring and firmlevel employment request pdf. Impact of offshore outsourcing of it services on the us economy 75 locations such as cognizant, infosys, and igate as opposed to offshoring when a single multinational firm moving work from its domestic sites to overseas affiliate such as ibm. In this paper we focus on trends observable in european countries. The results depend on the behavior of the markup on unit costs. Offshoring vs outsourcing difference and comparison diffen. Trends in offshoring business facilities area economic.
Offshoring is represented as laborsaving importusing technical change. Offshoring and the labour market 1 although offshoring, which means the relocation of production processes abroad, is an ageold phenomenon, it has recently gained a new dynamic through the decrease in transportation and communication costs and dramatic advances in information technology. Offshoring has no effect on native employment in the aggregate, the authors said. We also find multiple equilibrium outcomes in the extent of offshoring and therefore, in the unemployment rate. This information can also help policy makers explore feasible policy responses. The phenomenon of offshoring is not really new, but it arouses just as much debate and concern because it is no longer confined to the manufacturing industry and low skills but now involves services themselves, particularly those to business. Furthermore, a firm can increase its domestic employment through offshoring.
Table 2 reports summary statistics for some of the key variables used in the. Offshorings impact on human resources your business. On the other hand, there is another school of thought that claims increased employment. Globalization, offshoring and jobs chapter 1 holger gorg 1 21 1. Trends and impacts isbn9789264030923 oecd 2007 table of contents foreword 3. It offshoring causes wage deflation for us workers competing with offshore labor. Pdf the impact of offshoring on home countrys employment. First, the report defines offshoring in detail, allowing readers to see the many ways that industrial activityboth in manufacturing and in servicescan be transferred abroad. Nae website impacts and trends of offshoring engineering. Special focus will be given to the impact of offshoring on employment and.
Job creation abroad through offshoring may come with job destruction at home. We start with an overview of the measurement of offshoring, organizing our discussion around the three key elements of offshoring. On the whole, both outsourcing and offshoring are on the rise. A globalizing economy along with inexpensive telecommunications technology is making it easier for many jobs that were previously immune to offshoring to be sent overseas. As has been pointed out in level design, and sophisticated engineering tasks. And then there are companies engaged in onsite offshore. Nov 01, 20 what our government has done as regards the offshoring of our manufacturing has nothing to do with fairness or anything else.
The phenomenon of offshoring is not really new, but it arouses just as much debate and concern because it is no longer confined to the manufacturing industry and low. The hr staff is most able to determine how the selected company would be able to handle your companys requirements, matching what functions you want to outsource with countries and companies that have demonstrated expertise in those areas. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The story for the 1990s and later is quite different. Any discussion of offshoring business operations should involve hr leadership because of the effect on personnel. Read chapter industry trends in engineering offshoring vivek wadhwa. Revisiting the employment impact of offshoring request pdf. The estimates may understate the total impact because domestic companies with expanding worldwide employment may have located many of their newly created jobs abroad even when they did not reduce their u. Annette bernhardt institute for research on labor and employment, uc berkeley. This pace of offshoring also equals only 5 percent of the average annual gain in nonfarm payroll employment over the last ten years. It is part of a wider plan to bring the rest of the world living standard up, while slowly getting us to a lower standard. In chapter 1, offshoring is defined as the total or partial transfer of an industrial activity manufacturing or services abroad, either to an existing or new affiliate, or. The report then describes the wideranging effects that offshoring can have on domestic employmentthe positive, as well as the negative.
The most widely debated question is whether offshoring leads to employment losses or gains within an industry, and this is something we have looked at in detailed analysis of the 66,000 uk firms in our sample. Offshoring, industry heterogeneity and employment isigrowth. On the other hand, there is another school of thought that claims increased employment overseas has led to increased employment domestically. Offshoring or offshore outsourcing and job loss among u. Some believe that offshoring has resulted in significant job losses and that the labor standards in developing nations are lower than in wealthy nations.
For offshoring to have a positive effect on domestic employment, the efficiency gains it generates must be large enough to adequately boost the overall number of jobs. Aug 01, 2004 offshoring, import competition, and the jobless recovery. In considering international offshoring, two trends scream out for our attention. It says that increased international exchange with lowincome countries has depressed us wages. Jul 30, 2014 offshoring, the practice of moving production to foreign locales while continuing to sell goods to the u. Economic and policy analysis alavi, struss, chang and kim 7 and more white collar workers are being laid off from their companies as their jobs are shipped overseas. The productivity gains due to offshoring may, in part, accrue to workers. There has continued to be an increase in the relative wage of skilled workers in u.
216 431 133 744 692 294 1206 1138 1034 227 692 664 927 606 1248 1480 443 1530 527 1518 501 681 982 650 306 422 1309 1294 785 555 1361 759 396 1150 880